Showing posts with label Articles. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Articles. Show all posts

Thursday, September 12, 2013

The Price of Rejecting the Free Market

In an era afflicted by both economic and political turmoils, it is now popular to blame the profit motivation inherent in capitalism as the primary root for our suffering. Most people think that the proper way to do it is to get away with profit motivation and replace it with an idealism for common good where individual interest has no place. And so the alternative is sacrificial service for public good. However, this is inconsistent to human nature and facts show that such mindset not only fails to achieve its goal, but produces far greater sufferings. 

The best examples of such dream are the public servants, the politicians especially the "champions" of the poor. See the inconsistency between what they say and what they do. They make us believe that the reason they decided to enter public service is for common good. And we are so naive to believe their words. But in practice, you see that their real motivation is self-interest. The sad thing is, there's no way we can directly punish them. Unlike in the free market where profit is the goal, a customer can easily punish an entrepreneur if the latter renders a poor service. 



In bureaucratic system, which characterizes our existing politics, if someone is charged of corruption, all we can see are complex procedures and pointing of fingers and it is fortunate if we can see the real culprit punished for his crime. This is the price of rejecting the free market system and blindly accepting the bureaucratic system, which is a subtle way to curtail our freedom due to powerful influence of socialistic ideas. 

Thursday, September 5, 2013

Socialism - Definitions and Versions

Just recently, I realized that defining socialism is a very challenging task. Last August 22, I started a thread in a Facebook group composed of Filipino pastors, theologians and educators. I asked this question, "Should Reformed and Evangelicals support socialism as an economic system or not? Why?"

Pastors are divided. There are those who advocate Christian socialism. Others would defend the free market. But still others think that a mixture of two systems is possible. 

The Difficulty of Defining Socialism

Someone suggested to define the term first. I searched and came up with the following definitions:

Wikipedia's definition is not easy. However, there are at least two important things to bear in mind. 

First, concerning the conventional definition, "Socialism is an economic system characterised by social ownership of the means of production and cooperative management of the economy." In this definition, we need to further clarify the meaning of "social ownership" and "cooperative management". In continuing the definition given by Wikipedia, it appears that "social ownership" and "cooperative management" are closely connected. And under the umbrella of "social ownership", "cooperative enterprises, common ownership, state ownership, citizen ownership of equity, or any combination of these" are included. So as for me, this definition is not easy to grasp and if this is what we understand by socialism, no wonder, the question is difficult to answer.

Second, Wikipedia also identified that "varieties' of socialism exist "and there is no single definition encapsulating all of them." And then Wikipedia mentioned about "markets" and "productive institutions" and I think this is the reason why some people believe that under socialism, a free market can exist. Moreover, i consider that the most important insight Wikipedia pointed out is about the "role of the state in constructing socialism". 

After reading this difficult definition, I asked, "Is this really true in practice? Are all forms of socialism similar to Soviet or North Korean models? How about the German version? And how about the kibbutz, the commune and Scandinavia?

A Clearer Definition of Socialism

At Mises Wiki, this is the given definition: "Socialism is the system of social organization in which private property and the distribution of income are subject to social control; it also refers to the political movements aimed at putting that system into practice." This definition is clear and this is the meaning I would like to adopt in my question above. 

Furthermore, since I think it is related, I would like to include two insights Mises mentioned in his book, "Socialism: An Economic and Sociological Analysis." They are about socialism's aim and the seeming existence of the free market under socialism. Mises named this aim as the transfer of " the means of production from private ownership to the ownership of organized society, to the State" (1951, p.56). And regarding the free market, this is how Mises interpreted its existence under socialism:

"If the State takes the power of disposal from the owner piecemeal, by extending its influence over production; if its power to determine what direction production shall take and what kind of production there shall be, is increased, then the owner is left at last with nothing except the empty name of ownership, and property has passed into the hands of the State" (ibid.).

Some Ideas to Consider for an Extended Definition of Socialism

However, if you are looking for a longer definition of socialism, I think Mises' second lecture in Argentina dated 1959 would help. You can find that lecture in his book, "Economic Policy: Thoughts for Today and Tomorrow". Some of the ideas and economic realities evident under socialism are as follows:

  • The lost of economic freedom

  • Priority of the interest of the State 

  • Government ownership of means of production 

  • Absence of consumer sovereignty

  • The sovereignty of the state over the people

  • Use of laws to "protect" (coerce) the people from economic mistakes 

  • The absence of middle class and the division of social classes into two - the planners and the people

  • Socialism's economic system is characterized by centralized planning despite its impossibility to calculate the real situation in the "market" due to the absence of price system. 
However, Mises admitted that socialism requires an "exhaustive treatment", which was impossible for him to accomplish in six lectures. He advised his readers to consult his other books particularly "Human Action" and also to read the book of a socialist Polish economist Oskar Lange to see the other side of the story.



Other Versions of Socialism

Another discovery that surprised me recently was the realization that even during the early history of the Austrian school of economics, two traditions already existed - the Eugen von Bohm-Bawerk tradition and the Friedrich von Wieser tradition. Ludwig von Mises followed the Bohm-Bawerk tradition whereas von Wieser tradition was adhered by “social democrats” or advocates of mixed economy.

In reading "Planned Chaos", I thought as far as Mises is concerned, there are only two versions of socialism, the Russian and the German or the communist and the interventionist. However, my discovery of "Omnipotent Government" shows that Mises actually saw three forms of socialism - communism, social democracy and Nazism or national socialism. 

Mark Thornton confirmed these three forms of socialism except that Nazism was placed under conservative socialism (together with feudalism, monarchies, and the US Republican Party). Among these three, the most popular and dominant is social democratic socialism where property rights are still allowed, but heavy on taxation,

Another Austrian author, Hans-Hermann Hoppe expanded the three versions of socialism into four in his book, "A Theory of Socialism and Capitalism". He shared similar thought both with Mises and Thornton concerning the nature of social democracy. He also confirmed the existence of conservative form of socialism. His new addition is the social engineering form of socialism. 

A Broader Category of Looking at Socialism

So far, we came up with four types of socialism. But still those types are not exhaustive compared to the broader framework provided by Wikipedia. The free web-based encyclopedia distinguished between two general categories of socialism, economic and political. From economic point of view, socialism has four forms - planned economy, self-managed economy, state-directed economy and market socialism. From political perspective, it has five versions (I removed anarchism for I think it has a separate root), which are libertarian socialism (synonymous to left anarchism), democratic socialism, religious socialism (Christian socialism, Islamic socialism and Buddhist socialism), social democracy and syndicalism. So all in all, you can come up with nine or ten versions of socialism. 

Conclusion

As expected, the Facebook thread was left open. Answering a question connected to a sensitive economic and political issues like socialism is not easy. The debate continues. As for me, at least my own reading clarifies that there are at least three ways to define socialism and more than four versions to see it.

Related Article:

What Price Socialism? 

Time to Wean Millennials Off the Lies of Socialism

Wednesday, September 4, 2013

Mises on Monopoly

In my brief encounter with the Austrian school, I commonly observe that the charge of monopoly against capitalism is immediately dismissed as a product of interventionism. The problem is most people I know are unaware about the existence of interventionism. The only system they know that is guilty of monopoly is capitalism. 



So I decided to study monopoly on my own to gain familiarity about the subject. I was able to find at least five sources from the web. These five sources include Ludwig von Mises' "Monopoly and Its Effects" taken from his book "Socialism: An Economic and Sociological Analysis", Hans F. Sennholz' "The Phantom Called 'Monopoly' ", Damien Manier's "Monopoly and Competition: Government Intervention and Its Effects on the Free Market", Sudha R. Shenoy's "The Source of Monopoly" and D. T. Armentano's "A Critique of Neoclassical and Austrian Monopoly Theory". 

Synthesizing these five sources would take longer time and so I decided to take one source at a time. At this point, I will go for Mises first.

In dealing with Mises' material, I rearrange the order of content according to the sequence I have in mind. I observe that for him, monopoly has two kinds. He also argues that among the fields in the study of economics, misunderstanding monopoly theory is widespread.

What is Monopoly?

It is popularly believed that a monopolist can do whatever he likes in fixing the price of a specific commodity. For Mises, this idea is false for it assumes that the monopolist is not subject under the law of the market. 

Others also believe that monopoly is good for it eliminates the waste of resources due to unnecessary competition. And since a monopolist could also maximize the division of labor, it is believed that this would result into cheaper production and commodity. 

Monopoly Under Capitalism

To understand monopoly, one must investigate first the condition that made monopoly price possible in the first place. The same law applies in determining both the monopoly price and the competetive price. The fact is, the monopolist cannot set the price that he wants simply because this will influence the market and the attitude of the consumers. Consumers respond to this, which affects the demand of the commodity. It will either increase or reduce depending on the price and the monopolist cannot escape this economic reality as any other producer and seller. 

Unlike other Austrian economists, Mises thinks that monopoly under capitalism is a reality that is difficult to deny. However, he qualifies this type of monopoly as limited to "specific primary production". In particular, he refers to mining. He accepts that monopoly can exist in this field even without government intervention. Other industries like oil, mercury, zinc and nickel, Mises thinks that monopoly can occasionally happen if the owners of these enterprises form an alliance. 

However, there are at least setbacks to this type of monopoly. One, when the income of mine owner increases, "production and consumption of their product fall" (p.392). And then, "A quantity of capital and labour which would otherwise have been active in this branch of production is diverted to other fields" (ibid.). Another setback is that the increase of income in a branch of world economy under monopoly would correspond to the decline of income in the remaining branches. 

This type of monopoly is normal under capitalism and still tolerable. What people usually blame as the monopoly inherent in capitalism is actually the result of government intervention. 

Monopoly Under Interventionism

Only through government interference that a monopolist is protected from both competition and the existence of substitute commodities. This type of monopoly is a common economic phenomenon among countries where socialistic policies protect the monopolist through the power of the State. 

Mises describes the impact of government intervention where the monopolist could derive "maximum net profit" from a higher price of a specific commodity even though the quantity of sales would be reduced. So such interference would result to a higher market price or monopoly price, greater profit, lower number of sold items and smaller consumption. But in order to do this, the monopolist must resort either to the withdrawal or the destruction of the surplus products in order to avoid the impact of the excess quantity on market prices. And so monopoly under interventionism leads to the reduction of wealth and people's welfare. This is the kind of monopoly attacked in these days. This could never happen under the free market

This type of monopoly enjoys special legal privileges such as tariffs and patents. Most cartels and trusts would never have existed in the first place "had not the governments created the necessary conditions by protectionist measures" (p. 390). Mises further states, "Manufacturing and commercial monopolies owe their origin not to a tendency immanent in capitalist economy but to governmental interventionist policy directed against free trade and laissez-faire" (pp. 390-391). 

Conclusion

This study helps me a lot by clarifying the distinction between two types of monopoly. It is now clear to me that from Mises' point of view, monopoly under a capitalist economy is much smaller and tolerable whereas under interventionism, monopoly results into the reduction of wealth and deprivation of the consumers' welfare.




Reference: 



Tuesday, September 3, 2013

What is national socialism?

"What is Hitler's national socialism?" asks one member of a Facebook group. I already wrote an article about this several months ago based on the ideas taken from Ludwig von Mises' book "Planned Chaos". However, I lost it when my site encountered a problem. So I thought the question is not that important that I will never return to it. But after reading several responses to that question, I decided to revisit Mises' book and start again from scratch. 

This time it's different. I discovered that Mises has another book, which dealt with national socialism far longer than the one he did in "Planned Chaos". 

In Wikipedia, national socialism is also identified as Nazism. Notable to this definition is the inclusion of the phrase "as well as other related far-right groups." Wikipedia elaborates under the "far right" or "extreme right", political groups or ideologies that support "social inequality and social hierarchy, elements of social conservatism and opposition to most forms of liberalism and socialism." "Religious fundamentalist" is also included. 

From the above definition, national socialism is open for further explanation depending on how you will take the meaning of "far right". If you will include capitalism in it, it is understandable that someone will say that capitalism and Nazism are closely connected. And also the definition shows that the political left or the communist version of socialism has nothing to do with national socialism.

However, Ludwig von Mises has a different interpretation based on "Planned Chaos" and "Omnipotent Government". In fact, anyone interested to know Nazism from Mises' point of view, understanding the whole of "Omnipotent Government" is important. The book has 304 pages, but Mises has a separate section exclusively focusing on "German Nazism" from pages 129-239. 

The material that we can read about national socialism in "Planned Chaos" is just a summary of Mises' thought. There we can read the intellectual influence that shaped Nazism, the anti - capitalistic character of Nazism, the influence of Soviet version of socialism and eugenics (I intentionally did not include here Mises' explanation on eugenics). 

Intellectual Influence

"Hitler was not the founder of Nazism: he was its product." Learned Marxist professors influenced his mind and one of them was Werner Sombart. Sombart once "boasted that his life was devoted to the task of fighting for the ideas of Marx" and he "declared that Führertum means a permanent revelation and that the Führer received his orders directly from God, the supreme Führer of the Universe. "

Before the rise of Hitler into power, the German universities had already been prepared to hate capitalism. "For more than seventy years the German professors of political science, history , law , geography and philosophy eagerly imbued Their disciples with a hysterical hatred of capitalism , and preached the war of 'liberation' against the capitalistic West ... At the turn of the century the immense majority of the Germans were already supporters of radical socialism and aggressive nationalism . They were then already firmly committed to the principles" that would later be known as Nazism .

Essential Ideas of Nazism

According to Mises , the essential ideas of Nazism are not of German origin. Their sources came from Latin, French and Jewish intellectuals. The only German ingredient in Nazism "was its striving after the conquests of lebensraum."

Nazism was basically egalitarian. It's aim was to attain "income equality" and "fairer distribution of the earth's natural resources." The Nazis "consider themselves as revolutionaries fighting for their inalienable natural rights against the vested interests of a host of reactionary nations."

So Nazism, contrary to popular belief, "is the purest and most consistent manifestation of the anticapitalistic and socialistic spirit of our age." Their slogan "condensed their economic philosophy, viz., Gemeinnutz geht vor Eigennutz (i.e., the commonweal ranks above private profit)." The Nazi believes "that profit - seeking business harms the vital interests of the immense majority, and that it is the sacred duty of popular government to prevent the emergence of profits by public control of production and distribution." So Nazism "therefore was more comprehensive and more pernicious than that of the Marxians. It aimed at abolishing laissez - faire not only in the production of material goods, but no less in the production of men."

The Soviet Influence

Nazism found an intellectual justification for mass killing through the example of Soviet version of socialism. The Nazis learned to use violence and "mass extermination of all dissenters" as their methodology to advance Nazism. In fact, Mises described the Nazis as the most submissive disciples of Lenin, Trotsky and Stalin :

"They imported from Russia : the one - party system and the pre-eminence of this party in political life; the paramount position assigned to the secret police; the concentration camps; the administrative execution or imprisonment of all opponents; the extermination of the families of suspects and of exiles; the methods of propaganda; the organization of affiliated parties abroad and their employment for fighting governments and their domestic espionage and sabotage; the use of the diplomatic and consular service for fomenting revolution; and many other things besides. There were nowhere more docile disciples of Lenin, Trotsky and Stalin than the Nazis were. "

So here is the summary of national socialism based on "Planned Chaos". I wish to study it in detail using the "Omnipotent Government".

Sunday, September 1, 2013

Keeping a Daily Journal

To surpass self is life's greatest occupation, says Leonard Read. One practical way to do this is by keeping a daily journal. After five days of doing this, I find it delightful and I saw myself more productive.



Read suggested that in keeping a daily journal, making an entry should be a regular discipline as you wake up in the morning and retire at night. This type of practice stimulates fresh flow of ideas. It includes both accomplishments and failures, insightful ideas from books and articles and any meaningful conversation both offline and online. The habit is beneficial for you to see gaps and inconsistency in your thoughts that need improvement. 

Read describes keeping a daily journal as a kind of "capturing device" or the way to intercept the beams (p.12). Abundant ideas are passing us by and without a tool to capture those ideas, a person will either stay intellectually stagnant in the midst of plenty or confused due to idea overload. However, there is one danger to avoid and that is to think that we are the source of such abundance. 

I like the way Read used the Mosaic Law in relation to abundance of ideas and ingratitude. The passage actually comes from Deuteronomy 8:17-18. What it says is this: "You may say to yourself, 'My power and the strength of my hands have produced this wealth for me.' 18 But remember the Lord your God, for it is he who gives you the ability to produce wealth, and so confirms his covenant, which he swore to your ancestors, as it is today."

The passage does not only apply to material abundance. I think Read is right that it is also applicable to intellectual abundance. Its source is not us, but the Creator who gave us the ability to think. Violating this law would bring punishment upon ourselves. 

Source: 

Read, Leonard E. (1976). Comes the Dawn. New York: The Foundation for Economic Education, Inc.




Saturday, August 31, 2013

Internal Freedom

Leonard Read in this chapter talks about inward freedom particularly in relation to looking down on someone. This is a difficult temptation to resist especially these days where discussions in social network are widespread. Most people are in the habit of name calling when they observe that someone does not see what they see or people are saying things they don't approve (p.11). 

Perhaps the way Read labels the ability to overcome the above temptation as inner freedom is something unpopular to many, but the essence of it is not new. Read claims that he based his concept from the New Testament referring in particular to the warning of the Lord in the Gospels, "...whosoever shall say, Thou fool, shall be in danger of hell fire." 

Read has a high regard for the New Testament especially the Sermon on the Mount. Two psychiarists served as his guides in this kind of perception. They are Dr. Fritz Kunkel and Dr. James T. Fisher (p. 12). He shared with Dr. Kunkel's belief about the New Testament:

"But we have only one book which gives us the full description of the human situation, and of the way leading through all troubles and frustrations, and finally into utmost light. It is the great textbook of depth-psychology: The New Testament" (ibid.)

I just wonder why the Old Testament is not included. Anyway, to continue in despising others, says Read, will actually harm you more than the person whom you despised. You will have a new enemy. His mind will be closed to you no matter how insightful your words are. He will no longer listen to you. Read equates this in sinking your own ship (p. 15). 

And then Read mentioned about four prayer concerns. I find the first prayer concern very personal, the noble desire to straighten out someone's thought (p. 16). Inner freedom can never be achieved unless we learn to let go of that desire to manage someone's life. A "know-it-all person" will always remain a stranger to this kind of freedom. And so I made this prayer: " I am an angry man. I am a know-it-all person. I ask for forgiveness Lord. Make me a loving person instead. Grant me the grace of humility to see my mistake." 

Indeed, "The better world begins with that man who attends to his inner freedom" (p. 17). Amen! 


Reference:

Read, Leonard E. (1973). Who's Listening? New York: The Foundation for Economic Education, Inc.

Vision of Limited Government and Prosperity

This new discipline of keeping a daily journal was ignited by my reading of Leonard Read's books. Three days ago, I wrote in my journal that I read three chapters from three separate books. They are "Vision", "Thou Fool" and "Life's Greatest Occupations". And so today, since my remaining task for tomorrow's worship is just to include two songs in the PowerPoint presentation, I now have sufficient time to start writing about my thoughts about these three chapters. Let me start with "Vision". 

-----o-----o-----o-----

The man was Lord Tennyson. Leonard Read described him as a man of vision, of foresight. Such foresight is an outcome of politico-economic knowledge (p. 4). 

To demonstrate the power of vision, Read cited the experience of the Pilgrims when they landed at Plymouth Rock. There was no development that time, but after seven generations, numerous countries were amazed and sent their delegates to inquire about the key to the Pilgrims' prosperity. Among four reasons, two caught my attention. Actually, they can be summed up in just one - limited government. 

If the government task is just confined in keeping the peace and pursuing common justice, that would be good for society and for economic development. Once the government transgressed this boundary, social and economic woes are the inevitable results. The modern day ideas that the government is perceived "as the endower of the rights to life and livelihood" (ibid.) are basically idolatrous. The state has usurped the rightful place that belongs only to God. Such ideas unless corrected will produce nothing but the erosion of society's moral fabric and increasing poverty.

Read without claiming such foresight, made prediction nonetheless, a very unfortunate prediction. He saw not a bright future, but economic disaster due to the increasing power of the government through socialistic means:

"I can foresee not the wonders but the disaster that lies ahead if our present decline into planned economy and welfare state-socialism continues" (ibid.) 

Reference: 

Read, Leonard E. ( 1978 ). Vision. New York: The Foundation for Economic Education, Inc.

Friday, August 16, 2013

An Economic Prophet Without Honor

The study of India's economy from free market perspective deserves a careful attention. Since 1946, the year of India's political independence, Indian economists have been debating about the most suitable economic system for the country. The three major contenders were the Gandhian model, the Bombay Plan, and the Nehruvian model. 

The Gandhian model is based on "village economy" and "trusteeship". The Bombay plan is interventionist. And finally, the Nehruvian model is socialistic. Nehruvian model won and reigned over the next 40 years.

The Indian crisis of the 1990s was simply a product of Nehruvian model. Among many Indian economists, only Bellikoth Ragunath Shenoy saw the destructive destination taken by his country. Shenoy was a student of F. A. Hayek (who was formerly a socialist but changed his mind after studying the writings of Ludwig von Mises) and a member of the prestigious international forum in the tradition of classical liberalism, the Mont Pelerin Society.

At present, the free market ideas of Shenoy such as liberalization and economic globalization are being used by India, which have resulted to two decades of economic growth. Unfortunately, Shenoy remains an economic prophet who hasn't received the honor that is due him from his own people.

This is the summary of the article written by Chandrasekaran Balakrishnan last July 5, 2011.

Monday, August 5, 2013

Detroitification, Statism and Progressivism

I assume that most Filipinos are not aware about the significance of the recent bankruptcy of Detroit city. For them, it is purely an American affair. 



I personally believe that there are lessons to learn from Detroit's downfall. In this post, I just want to identify three:

The Reason for Detroit's Bankruptcy. I find at least three interpretations as to the cause of Detroit's ruin. The most popular interpretation is the one propagated by the likes of a Nobel Prize Winner, Paul Krugman. For him, it is the fault of the free market and Detroit is simply a victim of free market forces. Yes, he accepted that bad governance contributed to the destruction, but primarily, free market is the one to be blamed. 

The owner of a blog, Mont Pelerin World does not see the role of free market in Detroit's failure not unless you equate free market with the automobile industry. To him, three forces caused the bankruptcy. Together with automobile industry, the other two forces are horrible government and labor union. 

Another writer, Robert Morley shares a different opinion. For him, the key to understand the situation of Detroit is to grasp first the reason for its previous prosperity. Morley accepts the importance of the dynamics inherent in free market economy, but they don't provide the complete explanation. The role of God and the keeping of his commandments are central in his understanding of Detroit's prosperity. And since God's commandments have been broken in terms of tax increases on businesses and productive individuals and the act of redistributing wealth., bankruptcy is an inescapable result.

Clarity in understanding the cause of Detroit bankruptcy is relevant not only for US economy, but also for other countries as well. This is especially true in our days when mainstream media keeps on feeding the public that capitalism is largely to blame for global economic woes. Not many people are able to distinguish between state "capitalism" and free market capitalism. 

The Role of Expanding Power of the Government. The failure to distinguish between two types of capitalism is due to inability to see the role and impact of government interference to the economy. Interventionism is the common term used by free market thinkers to describe this act of economic interference. Interventionism is an essential feature of statism. 

Broadly speaking, statism stands for a political ideology that the government has the ultimate source of power and authority when it comes to the formulation of social and economic policy. Daniel Hannan claims that statism is actually responsible for the Detroitification of the USA. I cannot avoid to think that perhaps, behind the smokescreen of poverty and corruption as the two primary problems in the Philippines, statism is its ultimate political source.

The Role of Progressivism. This is the third lesson I think we have to learn from Detroit's downfall, that ideas, particularly bad political and economic ideas lead into ugly results. 

Actually, this article is an offshoot of a thread in a Facebook group. I started a thread asking the question, "If there is any, what lessons can we learn from Detroit bankruptcy?" As the interaction grew, one commenter responded, "I think progressives are heading to statism." I affirmed his answer and another commenter asked, "What's your basis for saying that statism is the direction of the progressives and who are these progressives?" The first commenter replied, "You already engaged with them in previous discussions. The progressives are all "'cause-oriented groups' and those identified with the left."

I find the questions of the second commenter difficult and so I read further looking for answers. And I came up with two ways to answer his questions: based on personal observation and based on the history of progressive movement in the US taken from three articles.

Personal Opinion

First, based on my personal opinion, progressives are usually identified with the political left. However, since the collapse of Russian version of socialism in 1989, socialism took a progressive form and identifying progressives right now is not an easy task. But there are hints to recognize them. Simply pick up a newspaper and look for sentences or phrases advocating government's action to interfere in national economy, I think you can find a progressive promoting a statist solution. Sentences like these are now common place: " I urge the government to institutionalize _________"; "The government can expand the program further to provide capital to poor families", and; "Mr. _______ has asked the Aquino government to create a/an _________."

First Article

C. Jay Engel of Reformed Libertarian wrote the first article. He said unlike in the past, it is not easy these days to identify labels whether it be political or theological for there are stories behind those labels. 

His understanding of the history of progressive movement started in 19th century. The battle in politics during those times was between leftists (classical liberals advocating limited government, which is also synonymous now with libertarianism) and rightists (conservatives advocating big government, which I call statism). Unfortunately, the liberals neglected their intellectual roots. And due to the influence of Darwin's theory borrowed and applied by Marx in understanding society, the belief in the attainment of an ideal world through socialism became popular. In short, in 1901 to 1914, liberalism was abandoned and replaced by progressivism. 

The classical liberals who had been replaced were constitutionalists and since they were thrown out of their political house, in time they found a home among the conservative camp who strongly opposed progressivism. So based on Engel's story, "progressives took over the title of liberalism and the true liberals found a way to call themselves conservatives based on their commitment to the American tradition of life, liberty, and property." So now, in the US, liberalism means progressivism and answering the question of our commenter, we can say that progressives in the Philippines are those who propagate in the country the ideas of US liberalism.

Second Article

Walter Williams wrote "Liberals, Progressives and Socialists".  Following Ludwig von Mises' analysis, Williams thinks that both communism and Nazism are two different forms of socialism. He was surprised why the crime of Nazism received international condemnation and yet the communist form of socialism appeared to be exempted from such despite the high rate of its victims, which was estimated to reach 138 million. He suspects that it is due to high regard given to Mao Zedong among American intellectuals. I suspect the same thing when it comes to Marx's ideas.

Williams added, perhaps contemporary leftists, socialists and progressives would argue that their agenda is far different from that of the Nazi, Soviets and Maoists. But as for him, the test for a tyrannous government is not only confined in the existence of death camps and wars of conquest, but the belief in the "primacy of the state over individual rights."

He left a warning: "The unspeakable horrors of Nazism didn’t happen overnight. They were simply the end result of a long evolution of ideas leading to consolidation of power in central government in the quest for 'social justice.' ” At present, in the US, there is a "massive consolidation of power in Washington in the name of social justice." So for him this is the appropriate question, which I think is also applicable to the Philippines: "Which way are we headed tiny steps at a time — toward greater liberty or toward more government control over our lives?"

Third Article

This article caused me headache. It is very long and I find it hard to make sense of all the details in it. Murray Rothbard wrote this, "The Progressive Era and the Family" and he gave a complex and more detailed historical background of progressive movement. 

For Rothbard, to confine the origin of progressivism during 1900 to 1914 does not provide the complete picture. He mentioned two movements that are not usually associated with progressivism - these are mercantilism and revival movement.

Based on Rothbard's narration, the revival movement during the 1830s played a big role in the birth of progressivism. This movement was opposed to "creedal Calvinist churches that stressed the importance of obeying God's law as expressed in the church creed." For this movement, creeds, rituals and liturgies are not important. Rothbard called this movement new "Pietism" and it has two different forms - "salvationists pietists" of the South and the "evangelical pietists" of the North, the territory of the Yankees. 

Since this movement removed the law of God as expressed in church creed from its previous place in society, but considered social sanctification as its mission, the remaining option to accomplish this mission was to use the power of the state. Exactly at this point, Rothbard described "evangelical pietists" as "natural 'cultural imperialists,' people who were wont to impose their values and morality on other groups; as such, they took quite naturally to imposing their form of pietism through whatever means were available, including the use of the coercive power of the state."

Rothbard mentioned some of the important features in the Progressive movement. They are the following: 

  • Use of both pietistic and scientific arguments to achieve the pietist goals

  • Social gospel movement

  • Increase of government contracts to business

  • Taxpayer-financed welfare state

  • Expansion of the power of the public school 

  • Expansion of the power of the state over the family, and 

  • Eugenics movement 

Rothbard's story is very interesting, but long. I just selected sections in it relevant to the questions of the second commenter: 

"Progressivism was, to a great extent, the culmination of the pietist Protestant political impulse, the urge to regulate every aspect of American life, economic and moral—even the most intimate and crucial aspects of family life. But it was also a curious alliance of a technocratic drive for government regulation, the supposed expression of 'value-free science,' and the pietist religious impulse to save America—and the world—by state coercion." 

"All these trends reached their apogee in the Progressive party and its national convention of 1912. The assemblage was a gathering of businessmen, intellectuals, academics, technocrats, efficiency experts and social engineers, writers, economists, social scientists, and leading representatives of the new profession of social work." 

"In short, the Progressive Era re-created the age-old alliance between Big Government, large business firms, and opinion-molding intellectuals—an alliance that had most recently been embodied in the mercantilist system of the sixteenth through eighteenth centuries."

So I think, if we find it difficult to identify progressives today, it is not because they are few. I think they are everywhere....

Related Article:

A Brief History of Progressivism